On March 11, 2021, Facebook user Shore Shanidze published a post on her personal page regarding Covid-19 vaccines, accompanied by the table. The author of the post notes that it reflects the lethality and severe effects from vaccination. According to Shanidze, severe effects caused by vaccination are 72,8% in case of AstraZeneca, 49% in Moderna’s case, while 30% in case of Pfizer. The accompanying table, which is in German, cites the EudraVigilance – European database of suspected adverse drug reaction reports as a source of the information. In addition, on March 18, Shore Shanidze published another post on vaccine side effects, noting that the number of deaths from Pfizer and Moderna vaccines during 4 months is equal to the number of deaths resulted from other vaccines during past ten years. The table, accompanying the post cites the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System of the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention as a source of the information.
The arguments given in Shore Shanidze’s post are not correct due to the following circumstances:
Disinformation N1: 72%, 49% and 30% of severe effects were recorded following vaccinations with AstraZeneca, Moderna and Pfizer respectively.
Fact 1. In fact, these numbers reflect the total number of reports on side effects rather than total vaccination statistics, and the EudraVigilance system is cited as a source of information, where the side effects are reported by users, which requires further research and approval.
According to the table, as of March 6, 2021, 15 291 out of 21 172 reported cases related to serious adverse events, representing 72.8%. This percentage does not reflect the side effects of the total number of vaccinations. In addition, such table cannot be found on the website of the EudraVigilance database, cited as a source. The table also does not specify which geographical area the information refers to.
The screenshots, accompanying the Facebook posts, can be found on the Telegram channel “Fact Sheet Austria”. The channel was created on January 3 and has more than 3 thousand members.
Both patients and healthcare professionals can submit a report on the adverse reactions to medicines as well as Covid-19 vaccines on the website of the EudraVigilance, cited as a source. The system provides reports of suspected adverse reactions to three Covid-19 vaccines – Pfizer, Moderna and AstraZeneca – separately.
The website of the European database of suspected adverse drug reaction reports – EudraVigilance says that the European Medicines Agency has only limited control over the completeness or accuracy of the information contained in the system. According to the EudraVigilance, the information refers to suspected side effects, which means that the patient developed these events following the administration of the medicine. Thus, a specific case is reported when there is a suspicion that an adverse event is related to the medicine. However, this does not mean that any link has been established between the medicine and the side effect. The side effect may be caused by other factors. Accordingly, the report is based on the assumption only.
EudraVigilance also states that
- The information, placed on the website cannot be used to determine the probability of an adverse event development. The information on how long it has been on the market and how many people take the medicine must be considered.
- The data available on the website represent only a part of the information that European Medicines Agency and national medicines regulatory bodies use to monitor the risks and benefits of a medicine following its authorization.
The fact that the number of individual cases given in the database does not always match the number of side effects should be taken into account. In the EudraVigilance system, a single person can record more than one adverse event in their report.
Disinformation N2: The number of Pfizer and Moderna vaccine deaths during 4 months is equal to the number of deaths from other vaccines during past ten years.
Fact 2. No Pfizer and Moderna deaths have been revealed in the United States so far, the statistics specified in the second post reflect only the side effect reports from the users logged in to the VAERS system, and both tables belong to the Telegram channel Fact Sheet Austria, which cannot be used as evidence.
It is noted in the second table shared by Shore Shanidze that the statistics are based on the data from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) VAERS system. However, this table, just like the second table, is published on the Telegram channel and does not represent an official source.
On March 16, CDC published information regarding adverse events reported to the VAERS system as having occurred after the Covid-19 vaccination. According to CDC, more than 109 million doses of Covid-19 vaccines were administered in the USA in the period from December 14, 2020, through March 15, 2021. During this period, 1,913 (0.0018%) reports of deaths were submitted to VAERS system by the people, who received the Covid-19 vaccine. Both CDC and U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA) physicians study each report of death, and CDC requires medical documentation for further assessment of the reports. A review of clinical information, including, deaths certificates, autopsy, and medical cards have not revealed any evidence that vaccination caused patient deaths.
For more on the VAERS system, see Myth Detector’s publication:
- What is the VAERS system and what do we know about the vaccination process in the USA?
Data on the adverse events of vaccines
According to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, severe allergic reactions can occur after any vaccination. For example, Anaphylaxis, which Covid-19 vaccines may cause, occurs very rarely, and a review of the events reflected in the VAERS system has shown that it occurred in approximately 2 to 5 people per million who received a Covid-19 vaccine in the United States. At the same time, if such a reaction occurs, doctors can immediately and effectively treat it.
According to Amiran Gamkrelidze, director of the Center for Disease Control in Georgia, out of 60 million people vaccinated in EU countries, 16,8% had serious side effects and none of these cases resulted in death.
According to The Times of Israel, 6,575 out of 2,768,200 Israelis sought medical help due to side effects occurred after the administration of the first dose of Pfizer, which is 0.24%. After vaccination of 1,377,827 citizens, the number of such people following the administration of the second dose was 3,592-ს (0.26%). It is noteworthy that 17 patients per million required hospitalization after the administration of the first dose, while 3 patients per million – after the second shot.
In case of Canada, as of March 5, 2 255 174 doses of vaccine had been administered. A total of 1923 (Pfizer -1061, Moderna – 862) reports of adverse events following immunization have been received by a database created by the Government of Canada, which is 0.085% of all doses administered. The number of serious adverse events among them was 214 (0,009% of all doses administered). In addition, there were 15 reports on deaths occurred after the administration of vaccine. However, a review of the cases has determined that nine cases were not linked to Covid-19 vaccine, while the other 6 cases are still under investigation.
The article has been written in the framework of Facebook’s fact-checking program. You can read more about the restrictions that Facebook may impose based on this article via this link. You can find information about appealing or editing our assessment via this link.
Read detailed instructions for editing the article.
Read detailed appeal instructions.